Home  |  Hi-Fi Audio Reviews  Audiophile Shows Partner Mags  News       

 

 

Enjoy the Music.com Review Magazine
Antonin Dvorak
Symphony No. 6 in D major, Op. 60; Suite in A Major, Op.68b ("The American Suite")
James Gaffigan conducting the Lucerne Symphony Orchestra
Review By Max Westler

 

  There are symphonies that present unique and sometimes daunting challenges to would-be interpreters. The Brahms Third, for example, has defeated the best efforts of some great conductors---Toscanini, Furtwangler, and Reiner among them. But the Dvorak Sixth? What could be more straightforward than Dvorak's sunniest, perkiest symphonic work? As one critic put it, "the cheerful nature of the Sixth, untouched by even a hint of melancholy, is perfectly matched by its uncomplicated structure." What could be simpler, right? Wrong! For reasons that remain (to me at least) mysterious, the work has resisted the advances of some very talented conductors: Ancerl, Belohlavek, Davis, Kubelik, Neumann, Mackerras---and that's not a complete list either. In fact mid-level conductors (Alsop, Chung, Kreizberg) have had better luck with it, producing acceptable if not especially memorable performances. There are two great recordings, however, both from the 1960's, and both with the London Symphony: Istvan Kertez and Witold Rowicki. Kertez is warmer, a shade more leisurely; Rowicki more electric, swaggering; but there's not a doubt that both conductors have the full measure of the work. Alas, in the forty or so years since those recordings were made, there have yet to be even one performance to match them. In fact we're still awaiting a great modern recording.

In spite of some very positive reviews, the young American conductor James Gaffigan's new release with the Switzerland's oldest orchestra counts as yet another disappointment. One critic characterized this performance as "light, transparent, and genial." And that's true enough, as far as it goes. Gaffigan, who won the Georg Solti International Conducting Competition in 2004, presents the symphony in soft-focus and without any rough edges. He does a commendable job at pointing details, drawing out inner voices, untangling thick-sounding orchestral passages. Throughout he emphasizes the lyrical nature of the work; he's sometimes beguiling and charming (as in the Adagio). But too often his interpretation lacks the animating spirit of folk music that so infuses the scores Dvorak composed during a period that also included the first set of Slavonic Dances. What's missing here and so evident in the recordings by Kertez and Rowicki is the unruly spontaneity of the dance. The scherzo (a "furiant") is just about the liveliest music Dvorak ever produced, but Gaffigan's approach is generalized, uninflected, so much note-spinning. The problem with this recording is not that it's too genial, but that it's too genteel. If ever a performance needed more rough edges it's this one.

The Lucerne Symphony Orchestra is better than most provincial bands, but not by much. The strings are thin-sounding, and the brass has no bite. The very clinical recording doesn't help much. We do hear everything, but at the expense of the warmth that might well have served as a saving grace. Gaffigan's talent seems better suited to the American Suite, a truly charming work, but not from the composer's top drawer.

There's a tiresome game we critics sometimes play: beating up on a new recording in favor of some favorite from the past (typically no longer available). Be that as it may, the choice here is a no-brainer. If you're interested in this symphony (and why shouldn't you be?), seek out the still very much available Istvan Ketrez on London: it's a truly great performance in sound that has the immediacy and warmth the present disc so sorely lacks. And it comes with a substantial bonus: an incandescent version of the Scherzo Capriccioso, one of Dvorak's most joyous compositions.

 

 

Performance:

Enjoyment:

Sound Quality:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

     
 

Quick Links


Premium Audio Review Magazine
High-End Audio Equipment Reviews

 

Equipment Review Archives
Turntables, Cartridges, Etc
Digital Source
Do It Yourself (DIY)
Preamplifiers
Amplifiers
Cables, Wires, Etc
Loudspeakers/ Monitors
Headphones, IEMs, Tweaks, Etc
Superior Audio Gear Reviews

 

Videos
Our Featured Videos

 


Show Reports
Montreal Audiofest 2024 Report

Southwest Audio Fest 2024
Florida Intl. Audio Expo 2024
Capital Audiofest 2023 Report
Toronto Audiofest 2023 Report
UK Audio Show 2023 Report
Pacific Audio Fest 2023 Report
T.H.E. Show 2023 Report
HIGH END Munich 2023
Australian Hi-Fi Show 2023 Report
AXPONA 2023 Show Report
...More Show Reports

 

Other
Cool Free Stuff For You
Tweaks For Your System
Vinyl Logos For LP Lovers
Lust Pages Visual Beauty

 

 


Industry & Music News

High-End Premium Audio & Music News

 

Partner Print Magazines
audioXpress
Australian Hi-Fi Magazine
hi-fi+ Magazine
Sound Practices
VALVE Magazine

 

For The Press & Industry
About Us
Press Releases
Official Site Graphics

 

 

 

     

Home   |   Hi-Fi Audio Reviews   |   News   |   Press Releases   |   About Us   |   Contact Us

 

All contents copyright  1995 - 2024  Enjoy the Music.com
May not be copied or reproduced without permission.  All rights reserved.