Home   News   Reviews   Show Reports    Partner Magazines       

May 2011
Enjoy the Music.com Review Magazine
Magnepan MG 1.7 Speaker
Its greatest strength is its lack of personality, excellent coherence and low coloration.
Review By Ron Nagle

 

Magnepan MG 1.7 Speakers  So many companies traverse the audio scene like meteors; they blaze across the sky and rapidly fade from sight. Some few manufacturers have endured to join this generation of Hi-End Audio. The Magnepan Company is certainly one of these. It began back in 1969 with a design conceived in the mind of engineer Jim Winey. Let me pause for a moment to clarify two words that could cause confusion. The speaker’s functional design is called Magneplanar; the company that makes the speakers is Magnepan. These two words are frequently used interchangeably. The Magnepan Company Magneplanar 1.7 speaker is an extensive redesign of a predecessor, the near iconic Magneplanar 1.6. Notably, the very popular, Magneplanar 1.6 had a 12 year long production run. The marking manager Wendell Diller informed me that the 1.6 speaker series was essentially a two-way design that could be bywired and bi-amplified. To date designer Jim Winey and the Magnepan Company have taken a basic design concept and continued to advance and refine what is possible.

 

And Now...
The Magneplanar 1.7 is now a three way full range Quasi-Ribbon design with a quasi-ribbon bass/midrange, tweeter and super tweeter. The term Quasi Ribbon refers to a fabrication technique that differs from a true ribbon in that the conductive metal is laminated to a thin sheet of Mylar film. The super tweeter in the 1.7 is improved by bonding the conductive aluminum foil to a much thinner Mylar backing. The Magneplanar concept is similar to an electrostatic speaker in that both produce sound by moving a membrane of (Mylar) film to generate pressure waves. Both of these designs are referred to as Dipole speakers. This is because the sound emanating from the speaker radiates in equal amounts from both the front and the back of the panels. The most important difference is that the Magneplanar design does not require a Hi-Voltage electrostatic charge to move the Mylar film. My Quad ESL 63 Electrostatic speakers had a separate Hi-Voltage transformer power supply in the base of each speaker. In the Magneplanar design, the magnetic field is generated by an array of closely spaced permanent magnets. The Mylar film has thin conductive wires or metal foil ribbon attached directly to the Mylar surface. The audio signal that moves the Mylar membrane in all of the Jim Winey Magneplanar designs is applied directly to the now conductive metalized Mylar film. Thinking back to my history with the Quad ESL 63 speakers the Magnepan design should be, and indeed has a reputation to be, very much more reliable. Evidence of this is a cult following by a long parade of entranced “Maggie” owners.

 

Physically Speak'ering
Magnepan MG 1.7 SpeakerAfter my significant other asks, what’s in that huge box and what are you going to do with it? ” That must be the Maggies”, my reply is also part question. Indeed inside the box are two Magnepan 1.7 speakers. The review samples are covered with black grill cloth and have matte finished aluminum side frames. Setting up the 1.7 speakers can be a two-man trial; they are very much heavier than I thought. Is this because of the combined weight of many, many permanent magnets? After peeling off all the packing, the first thing you need to do is bolt the two ‘T‘ shaped metal feet onto the base of each speaker. Provided for this purpose are eight 1.75-inch long Phillips head screws and four small plastic washers. The instructions tell you to place the plastic washer on the bottom bolt between the speaker panel and the metal stands. This arrangement will tilt the speaker panel backward slightly. The panel’s measure: 65 inches high by 19 inches wide by 2 inches thick and they weigh 42 pounds each with the stands attached. Since there are four terminals at the rear of the panels I asked the Magnepan sales people if it was possible to bi-amp or bi-wire the speakers like the 1.6, their answer was no. Also supplied with the speakers are spare 4 Ampere glass fuses for the tweeter panels and a pair of 1 Ohm ceramic resistors that can be used to reduce tweeter output by 2dB. (I did not use them.)

 

Set Up
The owner’s manual supplied with the speakers has step-by-step instructions on initial speaker placement. The two most notable statements in the set up procedure are the necessity to place the panels well away from the back wall and to toe in the panels toward the listening position. This first statement seems logical because of the panels Di-Pole radiating surface. The second statement is a bit surprising to me because of those very same large panels; I did not expect them to be quite as directional. The instructions recommend that you place the tweeter panels mirror imaged on the inside edge of each speaker. At the bottom rear side of the speakers, you will see that both speakers have matching serial numbers. Spaced to the right of the serial numbers is a position number. The instructions tell you to place the speaker with the number 1 on the right side. And the speaker with the number 2 will serve as the left channel.

A friend of mine who owned Maggies told me that they could be quite difficult to set up. Let me personalize that statement. As it turned out it would not be easy for me to integrate these large panel speakers properly in my 11’ 8” wide by 20’ long room. I began by placing the speakers were I normally start. That is with the speakers forming a rough equilateral triangle fronting the room’s 11’ 8” wall. As it turns out the Maggie’s are not optimized in the same set up I use for dynamic/cone driven speakers. Certainly in a much larger room the speaker positions could be very different. To make a long story shorter after some experimentation I settled on a placement that had to work in my room. Ultimately the Magneplanar panels were moved farther forward, now six feet away from the back wall. The speakers are approximately 8’ in front of me and turned facing the sides of my chair. In this is set up the speakers are less affected by the room boundaries and the objects in the room. They are now toed inward about 10 degrees and still 8 feet in front of me. The imaging at the center stage is rock solid. Even standing directly in the center between the speakers, I could clearly hear the center portion of the stereo image. Most certainly, it takes a tall Di-Pole panel only two inches thick to pull off this trick. Ultimately my goal was to arrange the large panels to recreate a performance that defies the boundaries of my room; this is where I want to be.

 

Philosophy
In the following, the words and the terms I use do not follow the same pseudo literati descriptive poetic phrasing you will read in the paper audio publications, phrases like, Palpable Presence or Vivid Aural Blackness. I believe it far better to refer/relate to the ability to channel emotions and meaning and not only to the sound, the equipment makes. It is all about the music, the equipment is only a means to that end.

 

Listening
As set up, we have relatively large panels in my room recreating a true Phil Spector style “Wall of Sound”. So what could be more appropriate than a vast and spacious live recording like, Party At The Palace [Virgin records CD 7243 8 12833 2 5]. The year is 2002, the setting the great lawn in front of Buckingham Palace, the occasion is The Queen of England’s Golden Jubilee. Gathered for this concert is the best talent in England. On stage are Queen, Phil Collins, Tom Jones, Bryan Adams, Annie Lennox, Elton John, Eric Clapton, Joe Cocker, Rod Stewart, Paul McCartney, Shirley Bassey, add Brian Wilson of the beach boys. All of them backed by, The Royal Academy of Music Symphony Orchestra with Brian May. I do highly recommend this recording. And did you ever hope to hear Brian Wilson performing Good Vibrations backed by The Royal Academy Symphony Orchestra? The recording contains the massed responses of a cheering throng. The effect is that you are transported to a grassy field and made part of the vast audience facing the stage. Every announced word and every musical passage echoes outward into the air finding you in the crowd. The music begins and the confines of my room recede. Like a time machine, I find myself so very alive, and in the moment.

The second track on Party is Phil Collins and the song “You Can’t Hurry Love”, the bass guitars deep cord changes sound so very penetratingly tribal. The result is exciting articulate and real, like a primitive heartbeat it effectively modulates your senses. The improvement inherent using the quasi ribbon midrange and bass drivers is there for you to hear. The bass guitar drives the music and underlines the emotional content of the lyrics. The sound is so very real that it seems like my Sanders ESL power amplifier is connected to the bass guitars pickups.

Not incidentally, the Magneplanar 1.7 loves lots of clean power and you will need to play these speakers fairly loud to hear what they are capable of. The Sanders ESL amplifier is a good match; it was designed to drive difficult electrostatic loads down to one Ohm. This amplifiers rated power into the Maggies 4 Ohm load is 600 watts.

My long-term test disc is, Basia (Trzetrzelewska) Time and Tide [Epic-EK 40767]. As far as I am concerned this complicated studio mix contains just about every aural clue I need. Let me tell you about the first track Promises, if your speakers have sufficient resolution the first line appears deep in the center between the speakers. Beginning within the line, “we forget about our promises” the microphone appears to zoom in on the stage. And yes, now Basia appears dead center within arms reach. The title word ends with a strong double sibilance, something that sounds like, “miss, sez”. I use this and other sibilant consonants to gauge midrange articulation. Through the 1.7, it is very easy to hear the teeth and palate micro overtones that tell you it is human in origin. The instrumental accompaniment contains high frequency information that opens up a space in front of you. With the Magnepan 1.7, this is good; this is very good.

Moving our audition farther, let us test the voicing of the Magneplanar woofers. To accomplish this I must refer to my long-standing bass reference: It is Adagio d’ Albinoni as performed by Gary Karr and Harmon Lewis. This was originally on a Japanese Firebird label but it still might be available via the Cisco Music catalog [GCD8003]. The real test is not to see how deep the bass panels can go but more important can they reproduce the overtones echoing from stone walls and the wooden body of Gary Karr’s Amati bass. Recorded in a cavernous Japanese cathedral this is a duo of a large sonorous pipe organ and Karr’s century’s old Amati bass fiddle. The thunderous reverberations of the low register organ pipes hold the woofers for a time on a deep sustained rumble. The resinous bass bowing sighs and breathes a mournful moan that tugs at your heart. The Magneplanar sound is chillingly organic and for moment or two, it feels like it is flesh and blood crying out to you.

 

Conclusion, Post Paradigm
Magnepan MG 1.7 SpeakerA the outset I wondered if any of the critical comments made some years ago in Magneplanar reviews would still be relevant. There was one comment about lower bass detail and dynamics and a few additional comments regarding the ribbon tweeter. Specifically the reference was to the speed and integration of the tweeter. It was said that the tweeter had better transient response in comparison to the other Magneplanar panels/drivers.

I found that none of these old paradigms proved to be true. Apparently, Magnepan and the Magneplanar 1.7 has evolved beyond any earlier criticisms. In fact, from my listening position the 1.7 is totally coherent. No driver panel, no frequency, no part of any performance speaks with a different voice. Only with your focused attention can the tweeter be detected, not directly but with a sense of expansive air and high frequency extension. There are a few areas of music performance bettered by different implementations. There are two speakers that I know well. The 70 mm ribbon tweeters in my Aurum Cantus Leisure 2 SE speakers, are specified out to 40 kHz. However, they are a very different treble experience, more of a point source like a Mini Maglite in a dark room. And then there is the greater delineation of depth from my Quad 63 speakers. This is marked by a layered separation of the performers on the stage from front to back. However if its dynamics, extended bass and a sense of excitement you value, the Quad ESL 63 won’t get you there.

How many ways to tell you about the personality, not of a person, but the Magnepan 1.7? Its greatest strength is its lack of personality, excellent coherence and low coloration. Every thing about it tells you everything you hear is the truth. In my room the 1.7 can be intimate or they can be an exciting and formidable presence easily able to take control of the listener and the listening space. Finally, I can only echo what others have said before me, the Magnepan 1.7 speakers are unique, an amazing performance, at $1995 nothing near this price can compare. Semper hi-fi

 

Reference System
Marantz DV8400 Universal CD player, Cambridge Audio Discmagic-1 CD transport, Cambridge S-700 Isomagic HDCD D/A Converter, ART DI/O Up sampling D/A and A/D processor, Magnum Dynalab FT 101a tuner and Dynalab Signal Sleuth.

Speakers, Aurum Cantus SES 2, Onyx Rocket Strata Mini 4 way speakers.

System connections: Three meter Kimber speaker Cable 12TC, RCA, 3 meter, Wire World Eclipse-2, RCA, 1 meter Chord Silver Siren, 1 meter Audio Sensibility Statement interconnects, Audio Sensibility Impact SE 5ft. power cable and Kaplan Cable 6ft. 10 gauge IEC Power Cord.

Power conditioning: Richard Gray 20 ampere Substation, Islatrol Industrial 20 ampere ac line conditioner, Alpha Core Balanced Transformer Power Supply, Audio Power PE-1 power enhancer, Triad 2-ampere isolation transformer

Accessories: VPI Magic bricks, Argent Room Lens system, Room Tunes Panels, a comfortable chair.

 

 

Specifications
Type: Thee way full-range ribbon speaker. 
Frequency Response: 40 Hz to 22 kHz (+/- 3dB) 
Sensitivity: 86dB/W/m
Impedance: Nominal 4 Ohms
Dimensions: 19.25 x 64.5 x x 2 (WxHxD in inches) 
Warranty: Limited three years to original owner 
Shipping Weight: 95 lbs.
Serial Numbers: 100282-1 and 2
Price: $1995

 

Company Information
Magnepan Inc.
1645 Ninth Street
White Bear Lake, Minnesota 55110

Voice: (651) 426-1645
Website: www.magnepan.com

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Gryphon Audio

 

 

 

     
Quick Links

Twitter  Facebook  Pinterest  RSS          


Audiophile Review Magazine
High-End Audio Equipment Reviews

Equipment Review Archives
Turntables, Cartridges, Etc
Digital Source
Do It Yourself (DIY)
Preamplifiers
Amplifiers
Cables, Wires, Etc
Loudspeakers/ Monitors
Headphones, IEMs, Tweaks, Etc

Superior Audio Archives
Ultra High-End Audio Reviews

Music Reviews
Classical Music
Jazz, Bluegrass, Blues, Etc.
Rock, Pop, Techno, Metal, Etc.

Columns
Editorials By Steven R. Rochlin
Audiolics Anonymous
Nearfield By Steven Stone
Various Think Pieces
Manufacturer Articles


Partnered Magazines
The Absolute Sound
Australian Hi-Fi Magazine
CANADA HiFi
hi-fi+ Magazine
HIFICRITIC
HiFi Media
Hi-Fi World
Sound Practices
VALVE Magazine

Show Reports
Rocky Mountain Audio Fest 2014
California Audio Show Report 2014
Capitol Audiofest (CAF) 2014
T.H.E. Show Newport Beach 2014
High End Munich 2014 Report
AXPONA 2014 High-End Show
Salon Son & Image 2014 Show
CES / T.H.E Show 2014 Vegas
TAVES 2013 Report
Rocky Mountain Audio Fest 2013
Click here for previous shows.

Resources And Information
Music Definitions
Hi-Fi Definitions
High-End Audio Manufacture Links

 

Daily Industry News
High-End Audio News & Information

Internet Browser
Audiophile Internet Browser V12

Mobile Phone Apps
Android Audiophile App
Windows 8 And Phone 7/8 App

Other
Audiophile Contests
Cool Free Stuff For You
Tweaks For Your System
Vinyl Logos For LP Lovers
Lust Pages Visual Beauty
300B Tube Comparison

For The Press & Industry
About Us
Press Releases
Official Site Graphics

Stay Informed
Join Our Free e-Newsletter 

 

 

       

Home  |  Sitemap  |  Industry News  |  Equipment / Music Reviews  |  Press Releases  |  About Us  |  Contact Us

 

All contents copyright©  1995 - 2014  Enjoy the Music.com®
May not be copied or reproduced without permission.  All rights reserved.